And you forward to your own mail server which again does little to hide anything. It's still in your proximity even if it's not in your name so anyone able to obtain your IPs from the services you use would also be able to get the location of your mule. It gives you very little in terms of anonimity, which is why you'd go to Tor anyway. Authorities may even know who you are but will be unable to locate you.īut the mule only gives you some extra functionality, resilience, and is like having an email address just for spam or a home VPN endpoint. This way you anonimously create the account and then keep your location hidden using Tor.
#Login temporarily not permitted protonvpn registration
If you need it one time for registration while staying anonymous using a burner SIM will work just fine. Does that explain it better? Maybe Proton could have some better messaging around this, if their customers are getting privacy and security confused? If the criminal breaks into your email, or if your house is broken into and a hidden camera is placed behind your computer, it makes little difference whether you have end-to-end encryption or not, your privacy is still violated.
To use your example of emailing the police chief: let's say your threat profile is that you're being stalked by a criminal, and you want to email the police to give them information on this crime, but you don't want the criminal to know. Explicit features that are in the domain of "privacy" would be ensuring messages are deleted on a regular basis, or some kind of key cycling, or an anonymizing service like tor, etc. It needs to be used in combination with other methods and techniques. I think you are confusing privacy with security, which is a common mistake, not your fault - end-to-end encryption is what secures the messages, by itself it does not ensure that the messages get to the right place or that the encryption keys are belonging to the right people. If this requirement isn't removed by the time I renew my account I will no longer renew. Improve the internet.Īlso, registering a new account through Tor requires a phone number for verification, even though Proton says no unique identification is required to register. I expect Protonmail to educate users like this about how Protonmail itself can be turned into an adversary. If Protonmail isn't supporting these users, why should I bother supporting Protonmail? I advocate on behalf such people by supporting services like Protonmail with my money. They're all engaging in potentially dangerous activities. Think about a journalist in Afghanistan, a whistleblower in the USA, or a human rights activist in China.
If you can't come up with anything better for users, just fall back on your privacy statement verbatim and avoid any marketing language. This month, 60% of our users connected through Tor". We recommend all customers connect through Protonmail through Tor. "By default we don't log IP, but may be required to by law enforcement. Replace immediately with something clearer. Maybe in 2018 when I first began using ProtonMail it was good enough. Your homepage reads "By default, we do not keep any IP logs." All the Protonmail customers out there, what did you do about this?įor starters, I emailed Protonmail support.
0 kommentar(er)
